The 1940 Jefferson Nickel: How to Value and Collect This Historical Coin

The 1940 Jefferson Nickel holds a special place for collectors, combining historical significance and design appeal. This guide covers its history, design features, values by condition, and other important information for collectors.

History of the 1940 Jefferson Nickel

The Jefferson Nickel replaced the Buffalo Nickel in 1938, marking a new chapter in American coinage. The U.S. Mint held a design competition in 1937 to honor Thomas Jefferson, the third U.S. President, with a coin. Sculptor Felix Schlag won with a design that featured Jefferson on the front and his Virginia estate, Monticello, on the back. Over 176 million of these coins were minted in Philadelphia in 1940, making it the third-highest mintage of its kind during that decade.

Advertisement

Design Features of the 1940 Jefferson Nickel

FeatureDescription
ObverseLeft-facing portrait of Thomas Jefferson based on a bust by Jean-Antoine Houdon. Inscriptions include “IN GOD WE TRUST” on the left, “LIBERTY” and the date “1940” on the right.
ReverseMonticello, Jefferson’s estate, is shown with a flat front view. The phrases “E PLURIBUS UNUM,” “MONTICELLO,” “FIVE CENTS,” and “UNITED STATES OF AMERICA” appear around the building.
EdgeThe edge of the 1940 Jefferson Nickel is plain with no inscriptions.

Value of the 1940 Jefferson Nickel

The value of a 1940 Jefferson Nickel largely depends on its condition. Here’s a breakdown of its value by different categories:

ConditionDescriptionEstimated Value
CirculatedShows significant wear from being in circulation. Common and valued around face value.Face value
Uncirculated“Raw” uncirculated coins in excellent condition but not graded.$1.50 to $15
**Certified Mint State (MS65+)Coins graded by CACG, NGC, or PCGS at MS65 or above.$15+ for MS65, $100+ for MS67
Full Steps Designation (FS)Clear steps visible on Monticello; rare and more valuable.$100-$6,000+ depending on grade and quality

Collecting Full Steps Jefferson Nickels

A unique aspect of Jefferson Nickel collecting is the “Full Steps” designation. This label is given to coins where the steps of Monticello are fully struck and clearly visible, which is difficult to achieve due to the striking process. Full Steps coins from 1940, especially those graded MS68, are among the most valuable, with some examples selling for over $6,000.

Notable Auction Sales of the 1940 Jefferson Nickel

Here are some notable sales of high-grade 1940 Jefferson Nickels with the Full Steps designation:

GradeAuction HouseSale DateSale PriceDescription
PCGS MS68FSLegend AuctionsDec 16, 2021$3,172.50Light golden toning.
PCGS MS68FSLegend AuctionsFeb 25, 2021$3,525.00Secure Shield holder.
PCGS MS68FSLegend AuctionsAug 27, 2020$4,230.00Rainbow toning.
PCGS MS68FSHeritage AuctionsMar 3, 2016$6,462.50Nearly flawless.
PCGS MS67FSHeritage AuctionsNov 7, 2017$234.00Sharp Full Steps.

Conclusion

The 1940 Jefferson Nickel is a great coin for collectors at all levels. Its accessible price in circulated or lower mint states makes it a good starting point for new collectors, while rare Full Steps coins offer value for advanced collectors. The 1940 Jefferson Nickel not only commemorates an American icon but also captures a unique time in U.S. coin history. With its enduring design and historical significance, this coin continues to be a valued part of many collections.

NDT Home

FAQ’s

What is a “Full Steps” Jefferson Nickel, and why is it valuable?

A Full Steps Jefferson Nickel shows clear, fully struck steps on Monticello. This detail is rare and adds significant value to the coin, especially in high grades.

How much is a 1940 Jefferson Nickel worth?

Circulated 1940 Jefferson Nickels are generally worth face value. Uncirculated and certified versions can range from $1.50 to $15, while high-grade Full Steps versions may be worth $100 to $6,000+.

Who designed the 1940 Jefferson Nickel?

The 1940 Jefferson Nickel was designed by Felix Schlag, a German-American artist who won a 1937 design contest to honor Thomas Jefferson and his Monticello estate.

Leave a Comment